Are you an Administrative Professional with responsibilities for screening job candidates, participating in interviews, or making hiring decisions?
Hiring is one of the most critical decisions an organization makes, and when done right, it can shape not only the success of your company but also the culture in which your team thrives. While traditional hiring often emphasizes technical skills and experience, there’s another equally vital factor to consider: cultural fit.
When you deliberately hire for culture, the hiring process becomes so much more than filling vacancies. You’re carefully weaving individuals into the fabric of your organization, ensuring alignment with shared values, goals, and behaviors. Whether you’re an administrative assistant screening candidates or an HR professional setting the hiring strategy, prioritizing cultural alignment fosters collaboration, productivity, and long-term team success. Let’s dig into why hiring for culture matters and how to get it right.
Why Hiring for Culture Matters
Improved Team Dynamics
Imagine placing a hard-driving, results-first personality into a team that values patience, mentorship, and measured progress. On paper, their experience might shine, but in practice, conflicts could quickly emerge. Cultural misfits disrupt team harmony. Conversely, when a new hire aligns with your organization’s values and approach, they slide seamlessly into place, bolstering cohesion rather than breaking it down.
For administrative teams in particular, where collaboration and fluid communication are daily necessities, a single misfit can create bottlenecks or tension that slows everyone down.
Enhanced Employee Retention
When employees feel connected to the company’s mission and culture, they’re far more likely to stay and be engaged. Research consistently shows that cultural alignment is as important as compensation when it comes to job satisfaction. Employees who “get” the way your team operates are more invested in shared success. For HR professionals and administrative leads, this can mean fewer costly resignations and smoother operations.
Positive Brand Representation
Your team represents your organization to clients, vendors, and the wider world. Employees who embody and express your firm’s culture help hone your brand identity. For example, an empathetic administrative professional working in a client-facing role conveys far more about your organization than your website tagline or any clever branding trick. When organizations get hiring right, their team members become brand ambassadors!
Fostering Innovation and Trust
When there’s cultural alignment, individuals feel safer being themselves and sharing their ideas. Trust within teams grows when members genuinely value one another, creating fertile ground for innovation. Administrative professionals who feel secure are empowered to suggest solutions, work on improvements, and step into leadership roles. That psychological safety is key to creating a culture of innovation, alignment, and growth.
Identifying Cultural Fit in the Hiring Process
Hiring for culture doesn’t mean hiring people exactly like everyone else who already works there. Diversity in thought, background, and perspective is vital for success. However, alignment with shared values ensures your team can work well together. Here’s how to figure out if a candidate is a good cultural fit without sacrificing excellence or innovation:
Step 1: Define Your Organization’s Culture
Start by asking yourself (and your team), “What are the core values of this organization?” If you’ve never codified them, now’s the time! This is a vital first step, and one that many organizations overlook. Your core values are unique and should be more than aspirational; they should reflect how you and the team act every day. Your values and culture should be reflected in how decisions are made, how team members communicate, and how people are rewarded.
Do you prioritize collaboration over self-direction? Is innovation central, or is consistency more valued? Understand the unwritten rules of how your team works and thrives daily.
Step 2: Craft Culture-Driven Job Descriptions and Postings
When developing job postings, go beyond listing technical requirements or job duties. Highlight your organization’s values. Think of it as a lighthouse attracting candidates who resonate with your mission while gently discouraging those who wouldn’t thrive.
For instance, instead of saying, “Looking for someone who can handle a fast-paced office,” try, “We thrive in a fast-moving environment where multitasking is part of the day. If you enjoy staying busy and tackling challenges with positivity, you’ll love it here.”
Step 3: Behavioral and Culture-Specific Interview Questions
The best way to assess cultural alignment is to ask questions that inquire about how a candidate has behaved in certain situations in the past or what they value in a work environment. Consider incorporating questions like:
- “Describe a time when you faced a challenge working with a team. How did you overcome it?”
- “What does a positive and productive workplace look like to you?”
- “Can you give an example of a work environment where you felt you truly thrived? What made it that way?”
Listen carefully—not just to their words but to how they align with your team’s dynamics and attitudes. Don’t be afraid to ask follow-up questions as well. After someone describes a challenge they faced, dig deeper. What did they learn from it? How has it shaped their future actions? Do the answers align with your organization’s values?
Step 4: Be Transparent About Your Culture
Culture fits both ways. Just as you want employees to align with your culture, they need to feel confident that they can thrive in it. Be upfront about your values, working style, and expectations during the hiring process. If your organization is fast paced, say so. If mentorship and teamwork is big for your team, highlight that. Skills are important, but you’re not hiring solely for skills…you’re inviting someone into a shared professional ecosystem.
Step 5: Assess Soft Skills and Values Over Perfection
Of course, candidates need to meet the qualifications for the position, but don’t get too hung up on minor gaps in their technical skills if their personality and values align with your team’s. Administrative assistants, for instance, are nimble by nature. Find someone who fits into the team dynamic, and they’ll learn the nitty-gritty with time. You can always train on job duties, but you can’t always train on cultural fit!
Making Culture Work for Your Team
Once you’ve hired someone who aligns with your culture, it’s time to make sure your organization’s environment continues to be one they’re excited to return to every day. Here are some actionable strategies for fostering a thriving team culture.
-
Prioritize Onboarding
The first few weeks of a new employee’s tenure are critical. Use this time to immerse them in your culture. Beyond the nuts and bolts of the job, introduce them to team traditions, organizational goals, and why your shared values matter. Take the time to pair them with a culture ambassador or peer mentor to help them settle in.
-
Cultivate a Feedback Loop
Employees thrive when they know their voices are heard. Establish open lines of communication through regular one-on-one check-ins, team feedback sessions, or even anonymous surveys. Administrative professionals often work across departments, so gathering their input on team dynamics can help you spot cultural cracks before they widen.
-
Reward and Recognize Culture Champions
Everyone loves recognition, but it becomes even more meaningful when tied to values. Publicly praise employees not just for exceptional performance but also for behaviors that align with your cultural ideals. Did someone demonstrate teamwork by stepping in to help a colleague? Celebrate that publicly!
-
Encourage Flexibility Without Losing Focus
Cultural alignment doesn’t mean rigidity. Encourage team members to express their individuality within the broader framework of your organizational mission. Perhaps you allow employees to personalize their workspaces or adapt their workflows to suit their strengths while maintaining core values like transparency and accountability.
Vista Consulting’s Perspective on Hiring for Culture
At Vista Consulting, we believe that organizations thrive when they commit to hiring individuals who reflect and enhance their culture. With decades of experience working with administrative teams and leaders on operations, we’ve seen how deliberate culture-first hiring can drive both organizational success and personal fulfillment.
Hiring for culture is a strategic investment in the long-term health of your company. It helps you create an environment where individuals don’t just work alongside one another but thrive in mutual support. Aligning individual values with organizational culture creates a synergy where the phrase “just a job” transforms into a fulfilling career.
About the Author
Mary Ellen Murrah, SHRM-SCP
Mary Ellen Murrah is the Chief Strategy and Marketing Officer at Vista, a consulting company focused on operations and growth. She is a dynamic leader with a sharp focus on business strategy, human resources, and operations. Formerly President of a national legal case management software company, she has a deep understanding of the challenges of cultural alignment, managing teams, and identifying opportunities for business improvement. Mary Ellen is known for her ability to spot untapped business opportunities and drive impactful improvements. She combines her extensive knowledge of operations, team management, and marketing to chart bold, transformative paths for growth. Her expertise and forward-thinking, relationship-driven approach make her a valuable voice in shaping the future of the legal industry.
Website: www.vistact.com
LinkedIn: www.linkin.com/in/maryellenmurrah
